thought I would spark some debate here in response to a previous thread about downrigger rods. Not looking to wind anyone up but I am truly interested in some different opinions.
So what do people think about using gear that is a little light for the target species vs gear that is a little heavy for the target?
For example: I use a stout downrigger rod and fully agree that the smaller fish (coho, pinks, shakers etc) aren't much sport. They come in quick and are released quick. I never thought much about it until my recent trip to Bamfield and we brought in so many coho that we had to release (wild fish in outside waters) that it made me wonder how many would live and how many might die. I am no fish biologist but would lighter gear ie longer plays put more stress on the fish and increase mortality? Obviously on the big springs (20lbs +) the fight was awesome even on the heavy gear.
maybe it is just a philosophy difference between sport fishermen and meat fishermen. I got to admit I love seeing the line peel out but I love it even more when the fish is in the cooler.
tight lines,
Brian :beerchug:
So what do people think about using gear that is a little light for the target species vs gear that is a little heavy for the target?
For example: I use a stout downrigger rod and fully agree that the smaller fish (coho, pinks, shakers etc) aren't much sport. They come in quick and are released quick. I never thought much about it until my recent trip to Bamfield and we brought in so many coho that we had to release (wild fish in outside waters) that it made me wonder how many would live and how many might die. I am no fish biologist but would lighter gear ie longer plays put more stress on the fish and increase mortality? Obviously on the big springs (20lbs +) the fight was awesome even on the heavy gear.
maybe it is just a philosophy difference between sport fishermen and meat fishermen. I got to admit I love seeing the line peel out but I love it even more when the fish is in the cooler.
tight lines,
Brian :beerchug: