BC Fishing Reports banner
1 - 7 of 7 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
464 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Let me start by saying, I have been a member of this forum for a while now and have found it a great resource. The moderators on the board do a great job, and most of the discussions are kept fairly civilized with their oversight. I have a great respect for the job they do. However, I was a little surprised to see a post regarding fish farming immediately moved from the saltwater board.

I am not a member of the posters organization, but I do feel the post directly relates to saltwater fishing. To move it to the obscure environmental issues and fishing politics forum seems a disservice to the poster, and the salmon resource he is trying to protect. At the top of the saltwater forum is a sticky post regarding dolphin harvesting in Asia. Is that not also an "environmental issue" ? yet it has remained on the top of the saltwater forum for months. Looking down a couple of posts I see an advertisement of reels for sale by a local company in the saltwater forum.

I don't understand why these other posts are considered appropriate, yet a post regarding Salmon conservation is removed from this forum. I would think the issue of fish farming concerns a lot of Saltwater fishers. Banishing the post seems a little bit of an over reaction. Just my opinion.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
464 Posts
Discussion Starter · #3 ·
I would agree, if their was a little consistency in the policy being applied. Don't commercial sales belong on the advertisers forum or classifieds section?. Isn't a post regarding local Salmon conservation issues more pertinent to BC sport fishers than a petition on Asian Dolphin conservation issues. These other off topic posts haven't been relocated from the saltwater fishing forum. Why not leave the fish farm post in the Saltwater forum. It is clearly more pertinent to the local saltwater fisherman than several others currently on the saltwater forum. If people aren't interested in the topic, they don't have to read the post.

Not trying to start an argument, but if fish farming isn't relevant topic for the saltwater forum, how are the other ones more appropriate.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
5,453 Posts
TheBigGuy said:
I would agree, if their was a little consistency in the policy being applied. Don't commercial sales belong on the advertisers forum or classifieds section?. Isn't a post regarding local Salmon conservation issues more pertinent to BC sport fishers than a petition on Asian Dolphin conservation issues. These other off topic posts haven't been relocated from the saltwater fishing forum. Why not leave the fish farm post in the Saltwater forum. It is clearly more pertinent to the local saltwater fisherman than several others currently on the saltwater forum. If people aren't interested in the topic, they don't have to read the post.

Not trying to start an argument, but if fish farming isn't relevant topic for the saltwater forum, how are the other ones more appropriate.
It has been moved to the appropriate section of the site. Unfortionatly from time to time we do miss things, we are only human!! ::)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,812 Posts
TheBigGuy said:
Let me start by saying, I have been a member of this forum for a while now and have found it a great resource. The moderators on the board do a great job, and most of the discussions are kept fairly civilized with their oversight. I have a great respect for the job they do. However, I was a little surprised to see a post regarding fish farming immediately moved from the saltwater board.

I am not a member of the posters organization, but I do feel the post directly relates to saltwater fishing. To move it to the obscure environmental issues and fishing politics forum seems a disservice to the poster, and the salmon resource he is trying to protect. At the top of the saltwater forum is a sticky post regarding dolphin harvesting in Asia. Is that not also an "environmental issue" ? yet it has remained on the top of the saltwater forum for months. Looking down a couple of posts I see an advertisement of reels for sale by a local company in the saltwater forum.

I don't understand why these other posts are considered appropriate, yet a post regarding Salmon conservation is removed from this forum. I would think the issue of fish farming concerns a lot of Saltwater fishers. Banishing the post seems a little bit of an over reaction. Just my opinion.
I am a bit surprised at the posters reaction. I agree that the dolphin issue should have been moved to the environmental forum, but the environmental category was added quite a while after the dolphin thread was started and pinned. I guess we got used to seeing it there and never thought to move it. The pacific anglers ad has been moved as well. In the pas couple of weeks, I have moved 3 different PA ads to the advertisers section from other areas of the site. I do take a little offense at TheBigGuy's reference to "the obscure environmental issues and fishing politics forum" (italics mine). What is obscure about it. It is a forum that concerns all members. There are many members (myself included) that might fish saltwater once every few years or less. We try to put issues of interest to all members in areas all members are likely to check. I don't see the rationale in considering this move a "banishment". The decline in salmon populations is as great a concern for freshwater anglers as it is for salties. They do return to spawn in freshwater and are targetted pretty actively by freshwater anglers at that time. "I would think the issue of fish farming concerns a lot of Saltwater fishers." I would hope so. I would also hope that "a lot of Saltwater fishers" would understand that this concerns many more people as well.
 
1 - 7 of 7 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top